Acoustic Neuroma Association
600 Peachtree Parkway
Suite 108
Cumming, GA 30041

Two Opinions: One Decision
Thomas Sattler, MD

In 1989, I noticed that the dial tone on my phone was not the same pitch in each ear despite perfect hearing. I saw an ENT who did the standard hearing and balance tests, all of which were normal. However, an MRI revealed a 1.0 cm acoustic neuroma. It also revealed a second benign brain tumor, a meningioma. Because meningiomas frequently require no treatment, I was advised to watch the meningioma but decide what I wanted to do about the AN.

I began exploring my options. I decided to have the AN removed rather than watch and wait because of my professional plans as a dermatologist. I was planning to leave the HMO medical group where I practiced and accept an offer to start a private practice with an established dermatologist. But, before leaving the HMO practice, I wanted to be sure I would be okay to continue to practice. So I proceeded with the surgery. 

I selected a neurosurgeon in a different city. The tumor was removed with a middle fossa surgical approach. The surgeon felt he had removed the entire tumor even though the post-operative MRI revealed a small dot at the internal auditory canal. He thought the dot was just a blood vessel and could be watched on subsequent MRIs. Two months later I returned to work, and a month thereafter I accepted the offer to start my own practice. 

I continued to have regular followup MRIs. Two years after surgery, the “dot” was unchanged but the meningioma had begun to grow. I was advised to have it removed while it was still relatively small, so I had a second craniotomy to remove the meningioma. Then, within another two years the “dot” began to enlarge—the AN had recurred. My doctor and I decided to follow it rather than re-treating, hoping it would cease growing, but eventually it filled the entire internal auditory canal. When a very small portion began to grow out of the canal, the neurosurgeon who had removed it initially recommended repeat surgery, which I scheduled. 

Before the scheduled surgery date, however, I had an appointment with the neurosurgeon at the nearby medical center who had been ordering the MRIs and following my case. After reviewing all the MRIs, he suggested I wait an additional nine months and repeat the MRI. Then, only if it continued to grow should I have surgery. 

So, I had two well-known neurosurgeons suggesting completely opposite courses of actions. I, the individual with the least experience and knowledge, had to decide what to do. After lots of anxious contemplation, I decided I really did not want a third craniotomy, and if an experienced neurosurgeon thought it was safe to wait, I would do so. I cancelled the surgery. A few days later, the first neurosurgeon called to ask why I cancelled the surgery and encouraged me again to have it removed. It was a very difficult phone call, but I explained my decision and held firm. 

The MRI nine months later showed no growth. Subsequently I have had MRIs every two years and the tumor has remained stable…until six years ago when the tumor started to shrink! 

The neurosurgeon who suggested I defer surgery pending another MRI retired before that MRI was done, so he never knew the result. Then, fifteen years later, at a recent ANA support group meeting, I saw the name of the man who signed in just before me. It was that neurosurgeon! I was shocked. I introduced myself and gave him the follow up details of my case. He gave me a “high five” and we clapped hands high in the air. What a wonderful opportunity to thank him for his advice!

 

Reach Out

To connect with any of the patients featured, please contact ANA at 678-331-5369 or email volunteers@ANAUSA.org.

Share your story

Note: In no case does ANA endorse any commercial products, surgeon, medical procedure, medical institution, or its staff.

The stories featured on this page reflect the personal AN experience, perspectives, and opinions of the authors in an effort to increase awareness and provide a resource for support. The information and experiences shared in these stories should never take the place of professional medical advice.
If you have any questions about any content on this page, please contact us at editor@anausa.org. Read our full editorial policy.
 

Stay Connected with the ANA